Norse Myths: Scottish National Jazz Orchestra – Queen’s Hall

Led by Arild Andersen on the double bass, Tommy Smith on saxophone, and Patrice Héral with the drums, the Scottish National Jazz Orchestra create an up-beat, but slightly repetitive, night of music that promises a trip through the stories of the most popular Norse gods.

Four composers were given a suite each, building a personalised soundtrack for Frigg, Thor, Odin, and Loki, however it becomes difficult to distinguish between the suites until the conclusion of the evening, in which Loki’s themes are slower and possess a cunning sexiness to them. The others appear to compete with one another for the most heroic and complex composition, and despite the programme detailing the significant ideas that are are to be conveyed throughout, they unsuccessfully blend into one long piece.

Adapted from traditional Norwegian folk music, the transposition of these ancient stories into loud jazz proves to be difficult, and the original heritage seems to be lost in favour of brassy solos. Vinaccia drums like a man possessed, full of somewhat intimidating energy as he provides the percussion for the band, Smith’s skills with a saxophone clearly demonstrate his confidence, and Andersen’s pizzicato bars manage an impressive speed that, as a former string player, I wince at. Their mastery of the craft, and that of the supporting band, is highly commendable.

If this had been a showcase of musical talent as opposed to a night based around a particular theme, I wonder if I would have enjoyed it more. The lack of commitment to intent became distracting, and although the performances were entertaining to watch, it was missing an extra something that would have made it stand out from a standard night of music.

 

PHOTO: The Queen’s Hall

The following two tabs change content below.

Zoe Robertson

Literature student at The University of Edinburgh - interested in new writing and voices.

4 comments

  1. This review is breathtakingly ignorant.
    Firstly the drums were played by Patrice Héral and not Paolo Vinaccia.
    The concert was greeted with thunderous applause from the audience who were clearly appreciating the great rhythms and superb solos.
    Were you really there?

    1. Hi Paul – thank you for pointing out our mistake, that’s since been corrected! With regards to the actual review, we’d like to point out that our reviewer did enjoy the show, but simply found that the style did not match the theme. We’re very glad you enjoyed the performance! Wishing you a pleasant Wednesday afternoon.

      1. It was folk songs they were performing and there were plenty of Norse folk rhythms present.
        It would be great if reviews could be written by folk who have some knowledge of the subject they are discussing..Jazz is feeling and rhythm..”Style” is minimal

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.